Note: Homily for Proper 28A, Sunday 15 November 2026, based on Matthew 25:14-30. This is the text of my second sermon as a lay preacher at St John's Episcopal Church, Lodi, California. Once again I'm grateful to Jef Cornelius-White for giving me early access to his new translation of the Gospel of Matthew, which I've relied on in a couple of places here. A video of the service can be found at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mQwzsxLY56s . The homily begins at 22:55.
In the name of the Parent, the Son and the Holy Spirit.
I have a problem with what happens to the third slave
in today’s Gospel reading.
Remember:
A master is going away on a long journey.
They have three slaves,
and apparently have eight spare talents of money
they want to work for them
while they are away.
(Side note: a “talent” is a very old word for a lot of money.
That’s the original meaning of the word “talent” here,
before nearly two thousand years of preachers
drew the obvious conclusion
that money in this story is just a metaphor
for resources in general,
especially one’s basic abilities.
So now, the word “talent” means one’s basic abilities,
but in Jesus’ time, it meant money.)
Anyway, the master lends the first slave
five sums of money to do something with
and the second slave two sums of money;
but the third slave only gets one sum of money.
Third slave
Youngest sibling
Always last and least
Resentment builds
Hides treasure in field
Just wants justice and to be valued
The first two slaves are “goody-goodies”:
they invest the money they’ve been given
in something reliable and productive,
like an index fund that let’s say
doubles its value in 10 years.
The third slave, however,
buries the money in the ground.
(Maybe that would be like keeping it
in your zero-interest checking account).
More importantly, they appear to resent
having been entrusted with much less money
than the other two,
and they are probably also annoyed about
the passive income strategies of rich people.
So when the master comes to them,
they complain about the master
taking financial advantage of people.
In punishment for this,
the master angrily takes away their one sum of money,
and then punishes them
by throwing them “into outer darkness.”
In other words, this third slave is kicked out of town
and ends up unhoused and living by the city dump
looking for scraps of food,
…or maybe they even end up in a detention center.
Hang on a minute, I want to say:
This isn’t fair!
The master treats the third slave quite badly,
first shortchanging them
and then punishing them for complaining.
The third slave is marginalized in multiple ways:
provided with fewer resources,
viewed with low expectations,
then punished for being “wicked and lazy”
and critical of the master.
What kind of “Kingdom of Heaven” is that anyway?
This doesn’t sound much like the Beatitudes!
* * *
…. Ah, but did you notice that,
unlike last week’s parable of the wise and foolish bridesmaids,
Jesus does not start this story by framing it
as a way of talking about the transcendent divine order
(that is, the “Kingdom of Heaven”).
Instead, I read this story
as about the unheavenly, “way of the world”,
in which the rich get richer
while the poor get poorer.
Living as we do in 2026 America,
this certainly sounds familiar!
After all, according to a recent RAND organization report,
over the past 50 years, 79 trillion dollars have moved
from the bottom 90% of us,
to the top 1% of Americans.
This is about twice as much as the current US national debt
of 40 trillion dollars.
So: We can assume that income inequality
was a cause for resentment
in first century Israel, as it is today.
* * *
I realize that my “way of the world”
interpretation of this parable
is not the most common way of understanding it.
Generally, this story is seen
as another of Jesus’s “Kingdom of Heaven is like…” parables,
similar to last week’s gospel,
which we heard about from Betsy:
the Parable of the Ten Bridesmaids,
where the emphasis appears to be
on paying attention/planning ahead/trying harder.
This message is reinforced this week
by the beginning of the passage we heard
from today’s Epistle reading,
Paul’s letter to the Thessalonians:
“Keep awake and be sober.”
Down the centuries this story has been used
to convince people like me,
and probably most of us here,
that we should work hard, live up to our potential,
… and give of both kinds of “talent”
to God’s work through the Church and elsewhere.
Further, we’ve been told that
the more resources, abilities or advantages
we have in life
the more is expected of us:
To quote Luke (12:48):
“To whom much has been given,
much will be required”.
Or, more popularly, as Linus says
in the old Peanuts comic strip:
“There is no heavier burden than a great potential.”
I must confess that I have been given much
and have lived a life of privilege,
as a reasonably-intelligent,
academically and economically successful,
male-presenting person;
I am also an oldest child
and the child of a comfortably
middle class, loving family,
growing up in Lodi.
So: in my relatively sheltered life
I have been given a lot,
but what I have heard
was that all this privilege
was a kind of debt.
I have internalized that I have to
retrospectively pay back the advantages
I have been given.
As a result, I have spent much of my life
trying to “earn my way”
into the Kingdom of Heaven,
mostly doing good not for the joy of it,
but out of a sense of debt, obligation and anxiety.
* * *
However, at this point, at 76 years old;
I no longer see guilt,
about the many earned and unearned gifts
that I’ve been given,
as a good reason for doing good
(including giving to the church).
Where is the grace or joy in that?
I don’t want to take
these many blessings or privileges for granted,
but I do want to do good or give
out of joy,
with a sense of connection
and mutual enlargement of spirit.
In the same way, for all of us at St Johns,
we occupy a privileged position
within the Episcopal Diocese of San Joaquin:
We survived the worst
of the bad effects of the schism in the diocese.
We have a healthy, growing congregation,
including young families,
and an inspiring, uplifting worship team
and worship space.
We are very hopeful that we will soon be able escape
the distraction and anxiety of our mortgage,
which will help us better hear
where the Spirit is leading us,
which might involve some or all of the following:
-A fully-developed formation program for children and adults;
-Serving as a hub for culture and social justice in West Lodi,
with a range of concerts and other events;
-Developing Spanish language services
to better serve the population of Lodi; or…
-[Insert here your fantasy/vision
for what we could do here next]
In January we will celebrate 25 years
in this church building.
Over the past couple of weeks,
as part of the vestry’s Every Member Canvas,
I’ve spoken to several of my fellow parishioners,
and have felt deeply moved by the stories
of their faith and contributions to this place.
over many years and in many ways.
So I want to focus on the joy, the connections,
and the possibilities for realizing
the Kingdom of Heaven right here at St John’s,
the transcendent order of genuine interconnection
and right action.
To go back to the Epistle (Thessalonians) for today:
For God has destined us
not for wrath
but for obtaining salvation
through our Lord Jesus Christ,
who died for us,
so that whether we are awake or asleep
we may live with him.
Therefore, encourage one another
and build up each other,
as indeed you are doing.
* * *
Having said all this,
I want to take us back to the marginalized third slave,
languishing in outer darkness
where the mean master had them thrown:
hungry, thirsty;
a stranger;
naked, sick,
… perhaps in a detention center.
Because as a preview of next week’s Gospel,
I want finish here by asking us
to imagine lifting up the third slave
out of today’s story
and moving them forward five verses,
into the very next section of Matthew 25, where Jesus tells us:
“I was hungry and you gave me food,
I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink,
I was a stranger and you welcomed me,
I was naked and you gave me clothing,
I was sick and you took care of me,
I was in prison and you visited me”. (Matt 25:35-36)
May we meet this challenge, with joy and grace!